资源描述
麦田里的守望读后感
thenovelthecatcherintheryehasasettingintheearly1950s.thebeginningofthenoveltakesplaceatpencyprepschool.holdenleavespencyandgoestovariousandsundryplacesinnewyorkcity.
thebackgroundofthisnovelisactuallyinamentalhospital.theentirenoveliswritteninflashback.thereaderdoesnotknowthisuntiltheendofthenovel.holdenfailsoutofpency.itisnotthefirstschoolthathasexpelledhim.holdenhasayoungersister,phoebe;anolderbrother,d.b.whoisascreenplaywriterinhollywood;andayoungerbrother,alliewhodiedyearsagoofleukemia.aftergettingkickedoutofpency,holdenmustgohomeandtellhisparents.insteadofdecidingtofacethemwithhisfailure,hewandersaroundthestreetsofnewyorkcity,andcomesintocontactwithsomeinterestingcharacters.
holdencaulfieldisa16-year-oldprepschoolstudentwhohasfailedoutofschooltwoweeksbeforechristmas.severaldaysbeforehe'sexpectedhomeforchristmasvacation,heleavesschoolplanningtospendsome
timeonhisowninnewyorkcity,wherehelives.thoughholdenisfriendlywithmanypeopleatschool,andthoughhehasseveralfriendsinnewyork,heisconstantlylonesomeandinneedofsomeonewhowillsympathizewithhisfeelingsofalienation.thepersonholdenfeelsclosesttoishistenyearoldsisterphoebe,buthecan'tcallherforfearoflettinghisparentsknowheleftschool.hespendshistimewithavarietyofpeople,butcan'tmakemeaningfulcontactwithanyofthem.afteradayoffutility,hesneaksintohishometoseephoebe,butshedisappointshimbybeingannoyedathisbeingexpelledfromschool.holdendecidesthetheonlysolutiontohisoverwhelmingproblemistorunawayandestablishanewidentityasadeaf-mutewhowillnotneedtocommunicatewithanyone.onthevergeofnervouscollapse,holdenchangeshismindanddecidestorejoinhisfamily.hethenentersahospitalnotfarfromhollywood,andheistellingushisstorywhileinthisinstitution.atthenovel'sclose,holdenisn'tsurewhetherhe'llbeabletohandlethingsbetterwhenheleavestheinstitution,andheissorrythathetoldhisstoryatall.
thereareseveralthemesinthisnovel.
innocence-holdentriestoprotecttheinnocenceofchildren.
family-holden'srelationshipswithhisparentsandsiblingshavedeteriorated.
loss-holdenlosthisbrother,allie.
betrayal-holdenconstantlyfeelsbetrayedthroughoutthenovel.alienation-holdenfeelsalienatedfromsociety.
adolescence-holdenisanadolescentinsearchforanidentity.maturity-holdenisveryimmature,butbelievesthatheismature.mentaldeterioration-holdenendsupinapsychiatrichospital.failure-holdenisconstantlybeingkickedoutofschools.
sexualexperiences/frustration-holdenisatypicalhormonalteenagemale,yethedoesn'thavesexwiththeprostitutewhensheoffers.
alsothereareseveralkeyissuesthroughoutthewholestory.
firstofall,holdenisalienatedfromsociety.hefeelsthatnooneunderstandshimandthateveryoneisa"phony".hethinksthatnooneishonest,andeverybodywantstobesomethingelse.hefeelsthattheonlypersonwhounderstandshimisphoebe.hedoesnothaverelationshipswithgirls,oranyonebecausehefeelsthatheistheonlygenuinepersonintheworld.
second,holdenhastodealwithloss.heloseshisbrother,allie,to
leukemia,andfeelsatremendousloss.alliewrotepoemsonanoldbaseballglove,andholdencherishesthis,andspeaksaboutitingreatdetail.hisbrotherd.b.livesinhollywood,andisascreenwriter.holdenregardshimasa"phony"andhaslittlecontactwithhim.heregardsd.b.asafigurativeprostitute,whowritesonlytomakemoney,andnotforintellectualredemption.
anotherissueincatcherisbetrayal.holdenconstantlyfeelsbetrayed,andthatisapossiblecauseofhisproblems.earlyinthenovel,mr.spencerbetrayshim.hewasoneofthefewteachersatpencythatholdenliked.spencerbrokethenewsofholden'sexpulsion,andholdenfeltbetrayed.stradlaterbetraysholdenbydatinghisbestfriend,jane,whomholdenalsohadacrushon.whenholdenreturnshometoseephoebe,sheisdisappointedinhimthathefailedoutofpency.hethinksthatsheshouldaccepthimunconditionally,sohefeelsbetrayed.severalfactsshallnotbeneglectedinthisnovel.
first,holdenisanatypicalteenager.heisalienatedmorethanmostadolescents.healsoisinthemidstofanidentitycrisis.allteenagersgothroughthesephases,soeveryonecanrelatetoholdentosomeextent.holdenissociallyinept.althoughhehasmanyfriendsandacquaintances,
hecannotformlasting,meaningfulfriendships.mostteenagers,
althoughtheydohaveinsecurities,areabletofunctioninrelationships.second,holdendoesnotmaturethroughthenovel.heactually
regressesbacktoachild-likestateofmind.heisconstantlydwellingonthedeathofhisyoungerbrother,andavoidshisparents,andfeelsliketheonlypersonhecantalktoishistenyearoldsister.
anotherfactthatisessentialisthatholdenholdsallieandphoebeinsuchhighesteembecausetheyareinnocent.holden'sgoalistoprotectinnocenceintheworld.whenhehearsthe"catcherintherye"songbeingsungbyalittleboy,hedecidesthathewantstobethepersonthatkeepschildrenfromfallingoffacliff.thatcliffsymbolizesthetransitionfromchildhoodtoadulthood,andhewantstokeepthemasinnocentchildren,notphonyadults.
intheend,thecatcherintheryewillcontinuetobeapointofgreatpublicandcriticaldebate.onemustremember,however,inthestudyandcritiqueofthenovel,particularlyforaresearcherorcriticnow,thatthestorywaswritteninadifferenttime.iforiginallypublishedtoday,thenovelwouldprobablycreatelittlepublicityandgarneronlyaveragebooksales.
thefactthatanovelofsuchradicalsocialopinionandobservationwas
writteninatimeofconservatisminamericamadeitallthemorecontroversial.somecriticsscoldedthenovelasbeingtoopessimisticorobscene,tooharshforthesocietyofthe1950's.others,however,nominatedsalingerhimselfasthetop-flight"catcherintherye"forthatperiodinamericanhistory(peterson3).theyarguedthatsalinger'sconcernsrepresentedanentiregenerationofamericanyouth,frustratedbythephoninessoftheworld,justlikeholdenwas.
thepopularityofthenovelanddebateoveritssocialvaluehaveneverstoppedsinceitsinitialpublication,dueinnolargeparttothefactthatj.d.salingerisnowarecluse.itwouldbeconclusivetosaythatcriticsofthecatcherintheryehavelegitimatecriticismsofthenovel,whileadvocatesandsupportersofthestory'smessagealsohaveexpressedveritablepraise.
accordingtomostanalyses,thecatcherintheryeisa
bildungsroman,anovelaboutayoungcharacter’sgrowthintomaturity.whileitisappropriatetodiscussthenovelinsuchterms,holdencaulfieldisanunusualprotagonistforabildungsromanbecausehiscentralgoalistoresisttheprocessofmaturityitself.ashisthoughtsaboutthemuseumofnaturalhistorydemonstrate,holdenfearschangeandisoverwhelmedbycomplexity.hewants
everythingtobeeasilyunderstandableandeternallyfixed,likethestatuesofeskimosandindiansinthemuseum.heisfrightenedbecauseheisguiltyofthesinshecriticizesinothers,andbecausehecan’tunderstandeverythingaroundhim.butherefusestoacknowledgethisfear,expressingitonlyinafewinstances—forexample,whenhetalksaboutsexandadmitsthat“[s]exis
somethingijustdon’tunderstand.isweartogodidon’t”(chapter
9).
insteadofacknowledgingthatadulthoodscaresandmystifieshim,holdeninventsafantasythatadulthoodisaworldofsuperficialityandhypocrisy(“phoniness”),whilechildhoodisaworldof
innocence,curiosity,andhonesty.nothingrevealshisimageofthesetwoworldsbetterthanhisfantasyaboutthecatcherintherye:heimagineschildhoodasanidyllicfieldofryeinwhichchildrenrompandplay;adulthood,forthechildrenofthisworld,is
equivalenttodeath—afatalfallovertheedgeofacliff.hiscreatedunderstandingsofchildhoodandadulthoodallowholdentocuthimselfofffromtheworldbycoveringhimselfwithaprotectivearmorofcynicism.butasthebookprogresses,holden’sexperiences,particularlyhisencounterswithmr.antoliniandphoebe,revealtheshallownessofhisconceptions.
第9页 共9页
展开阅读全文