资源描述
Click to edit Master title style,Click to edit Master text styles,Second level,Third level,Fourth level,Fifth level,*,Click to edit Master title style,Click to edit Master text styles,Second level,Third level,Fourth level,Fifth level,*,Applied Econometrics,William Greene,Department of Economics,Stern School of Business,Applied Econometrics,19.Maximum Likelihood Estimation,Maximum Likelihood Estimation,This defines a class of estimators based on the particular distribution assumed to have generated the observed random variable.,The main advantage,of ML estimators is that among all,Consistent Asymptotically Normal Estimators,MLEs have optimal asymptotic properties.,The main disadvantage,is that they are not necessarily robust to failures of the distributional assumptions.They are very dependent on the particular assumptions.,The oft cited disadvantage,of their mediocre small sample properties is probably overstated in view of the usual paucity of viable alternatives.,Setting up the MLE,The distribution of the observed random variable is written as a function of the parameters to be estimated,P(y,i,|data,)=Probability density|parameters.,The likelihood function is constructed from the density,Construction:Joint probability density function of the observed sample of data generally the product when the data are a,random,sample.,Regularity Conditions,What they are,1.logf(.)has three continuous derivatives wrt parameters,2.Conditions needed to obtain expectations of derivatives are met.(E.g.,range of the variable is not a function of the parameters.),3.Third derivative has finite expectation.,What they mean,Moment conditions and convergence.We need to obtain expectations of derivatives.,We need to be able to truncate Taylor series.,We will use central limit theorems,Properties of the Maximum Likelihood Estimator,We will sketch formal proofs of these results:,The log-likelihood function,again,The likelihood equation and the information matrix.,A linear Taylor series approximation to the first order conditions:,g,(,ML,)=,0,g,(,)+H(,)(,ML,-,),(under regularity,higher order terms will vanish in large samples.),Our usual approach.Large sample behavior of the left and right hand sides is the same.,A Proof of consistency.(Property 1),The limiting variance of,n(,ML,-,).We are using the central limit theorem here.,Leads to asymptotic normality(Property 2).We will derive the asymptotic variance of the MLE.,Efficiency(we have not developed the tools to prove this.)The Cramer-Rao lower bound for efficient estimation(an asymptotic version of Gauss-Markov).,Estimating the variance of the maximum likelihood estimator.,Invariance.(A,VERY,handy result.)Coupled with the Slutsky theorem and the delta method,the invariance property makes estimation of nonlinear functions of parameters very easy.,Testing Hypotheses A Trinity of Tests,The likelihood ratio test:,Based on the proposition(Greenes)that restrictions always“make life worse”,Is the reduction in the criterion(log-likelihood)large?Leads to the LR test.,The Lagrange multiplier test:,Underlying basis:Reexamine the first order conditions.,Form a test of whether the gradient is significantly“nonzero”at the restricted estimator.,The Wald test:The usual.,The Linear(Normal)Model,Definition of the likelihood function-joint density of the observed data,written as a function of the parameters we wish to estimate.,Definition of the maximum likelihood estimator as that function of the observed data that maximizes the likelihood function,or its logarithm.,For the model:y,i,=,x,i,+,i,where,i,N0,2,the maximum likelihood estimators of,and,2,are,b,=(,X,X,),-1,X,y,and s,2,=,e,e,/n.,That is,least squares is ML for the slopes,but the variance estimator makes no degrees of freedom correction,so the MLE is biased.,Normal Linear Model,The log-likelihood function,=,i log f(y,i,|,),=sum of logs of densities.,For the linear regression model with normally distributed disturbances,log-L =,i,-log2,-log,2,-(y,i,x,i,),2,/,2,.,Likelihood Equations,The estimator is defined by the function of the data that equates,log-L/,to,0,.(Likelihood equation),The derivative vector of the log-likelihood function is the,score function,.For the regression model,g,=,log-L/,log-L/,2,=,log-L/,=,i,(1/,2,),x,i,(y,i,-,x,i,),log-L/,2,=,i,-,1/(2,2,)+(y,i,-,x,i,),2,/(2,4,),For the linear regression model,the first derivative vector of log-L is,(1/,2,),X,(,y-X,)and (1/2,2,),i,(y,i,-,x,i,)2/,2,-1,(K,1)(1,1),Note that we could compute these functions at,any,and,2,.If we compute them at,b,and,e,e,/n,the functions will be identically zero.,Moment Equations,Note that,g,=,i,g,i,is a random vector and that each term in the sum has expectation zero.It follows that E(1/n),g,=,0,.Our estimator is found by finding the,that sets the,sample mean,of the,g,s to,0,.That is,theoretically,E,g,i,(,2,)=,0.,We find the estimator as that function which produces (1/n),i,g,i,(,b,s,2,)=0.,Note the similarity to the way we would estimate any mean.If,Ex,i,=,then Ex,i,-,=0.We estimate,by finding the function of the data that produces(1/n),i,(x,i,-m)=0,which is,of course the sample mean.,There are two main components to the“regularity conditions for maximum likelihood estimation.The first is that the first derivative has expected value,0,.That moment equation motivates the MLE,Information Matrix,The negative of the second derivatives matrix of the log-likelihood,-,H,=,is called the,information matrix,.It is usually a random matrix,also.For the linear regression model,Hessian for the Linear Model,Note that the off diagonal elements have expectation zero.,Estimated Information Matrix,(which should look familiar).The off diagonal terms go to zero(one of the assumptions of the model).,This can be computed at any vector,and scalar,2,.You can take expected values of the parts of the matrix to get,Deriving the Properties of the Maximum Likelihood Estimator,The MLE,Consistency:,Consistency Proof,Asymptotic Variance,Asymptotic Variance,Asymptotic Distribution,Other Results 1 Variance Bound,Invariance,The maximum likelihood estimator of a function of,say h(,)is h(MLE).This is not always true of other kinds of estimators.To get the variance of this function,we would use the delta method.E.g.,the MLE of,=(,/,)is,b,/(,ee,/n),Computing the Asymptotic Variance,We want to estimate-E,H,-1,Three ways:,(1)Just compute the negative of the actual second derivatives matrix and invert it.,(2)Insert the maximum likelihood estimates into the known expected values of the second derivatives matrix.Sometimes(1)and(2)give the same answer(for example,in the linear regression model).,(3)Since E,H,is the variance of the first derivatives,estimate this with the sample variance(i.e.,mean square)of the first derivatives.This will almost always be different from(1)and(2).,Since they are estimating the same thing,in large samples,all three will give the same answer.Current practice in econometrics often favors(3).Stata rarely uses(3).Others do.,Linear Regression Model,Example:Different Estimators of the Variance of the MLE,Consider,again,the gasoline data.We use a simple equation:,G,t,=,1,+,2,Y,t,+,3,Pg,t,+,t,.,Linear Model,BHHH Estimator,Newtons Method,Poisson Regression,Asymptotic Variance of the MLE,Estimators of the Asymptotic Covariance Matrix,ROBUST ESTIMATION,Sandwich Estimator,H,-1,(GG)H,-1,Is this appropriate?Why do we do this?,Application:Doctor Visits,German Individual Health Care data:N=27,236,Model for number of visits to the doctor:,Poisson regression(fit by maximum likelihood),Income,Education,Gender,Poisson Regression Iterations,poisson;lhs=docvis;rhs=one,female,hhninc,educ;mar;output=3$,Method=Newton;Maximum iterations=100,Convergence criteria:gtHg .1000D-05 chg.F .0000D+00 max|db|.0000D+00,Start values:.00000D+00 .00000D+00 .00000D+00 .00000D+00,1st derivs.-.13214D+06 -.61899D+05 -.43338D+05 -.14596D+07,Parameters:.28002D+01 .72374D-01 -.65451D+00 -.47608D-01,Itr 2 F=-.1587D+06 gtHg=.2832D+03 chg.F=.1587D+06 max|db|=.1346D+01,1st derivs.-.33055D+05 -.14401D+05 -.10804D+05 -.36592D+06,Parameters:.21404D+01 .16980D+00 -.60181D+00 -.48527D-01,Itr 3 F=-.1115D+06 gtHg=.9725D+02 chg.F=.4716D+05 max|db|=.6348D+00,1st derivs.-.42953D+04 -.15074D+04 -.13927D+04 -.47823D+05,Parameters:.17997D+01 .27758D+00 -.54519D+00 -.49513D-01,Itr 4 F=-.1063D+06 gtHg=.1545D+02 chg.F=.5162D+04 max|db|=.1437D+00,1st derivs.-.11692D+03 -.22248D+02 -.37525D+02 -.13159D+04,Parameters:.17276D+01 .31746D+00 -.52565D+00 -.49852D-01,Itr 5 F=-.1062D+06 gtHg=.5006D+00 chg.F=.1218D+03 max|db|=.6542D-02,1st derivs.-.12522D+00 -.54690D-02 -.40254D-01 -.14232D+01,Parameters:.17249D+01 .31954D+00 -.52476D+00 -.49867D-01,Itr 6 F=-.1062D+06 gtHg=.6215D-03 chg.F=.1254D+00 max|db|=.9678D-05,1st derivs.-.19317D-06 -.94936D-09 -.62872D-07 -.22029D-05,Parameters:.17249D+01 .31954D+00 -.52476D+00 -.49867D-01,Itr 7 F=-.1062D+06 gtHg=.9957D-09 chg.F=.1941D-06 max|db|=.1602D-10,*Converged,Regression and Partial Effects,+-+-+-+-+-+-+,|Variable|Coefficient|Standard Error|b/St.Er.|P|Z|z|Mean of X|,+-+-+-+-+-+-+,Constant|1.72492985 .02000568 86.222 .0000,FEMALE|.31954440 .00696870 45.854 .0000 .47877479,HHNINC|-.52475878 .02197021 -23.885 .0000 .35208362,EDUC|-.04986696 .00172872 -28.846 .0000 11.3206310,+-+,|Partial derivatives of expected val.with|,|respect to the vector of characteristics.|,|Effects are averaged over individuals.|,|Observations used for means are All Obs.|,|Conditional Mean at Sample Point 3.1835|,|Scale Factor for Marginal Effects 3.1835|,+-+,+-+-+-+-+-+-+,|Variable|Coefficient|Standard Error|b/St.Er.|P|Z|z|Mean of X|,+-+-+-+-+-+-+,Constant|5.49135704 .07890083 69.598 .0000,FEMALE|1.01727755 .02427607 41.905 .0000 .47877479,HHNINC|-1.67058263 .07312900 -22.844 .0000 .35208362,EDUC|-.15875271 .00579668 -27.387 .0000 11.3206310,Comparison of Standard Errors,+-+-+-+-+-+-+,|Variable|Coefficient|Standard Error|b/St.Er.|P|Z|z|Mean of X|,+-+-+-+-+-+-+,Constant|1.72492985 .02000568 86.222 .0000,FEMALE|.31954440 .00696870 45.854 .0000 .47877479,HHNINC|-.52475878 .02197021 -23.885 .0000 .35208362,EDUC|-.04986696 .00172872 -28.846 .0000 11.3206310,BHHH,+-+-+-+-+-+,|Variable|Coefficient|Standard Error|b/St.Er.|P|Z|z|,+-+-+-+-+-+,Constant|1.72492985 .00677787 254.495 .0000,FEMALE|.31954440 .00217499 146.918 .0000,HHNINC|-.52475878 .00733328 -71.559 .0000,EDUC|-.04986696 .00062283 -80.065 .0000,Why are they so different?Model failure.This is a panel.There is autocorrelation.,NLS vs.MLE,NONLINEAR LEAST SQUARES,+-+-+-+-+-+,|Variable|Coefficient|Standard Error|b/St.Er.|P|Z|z|,+-+-+-+-+-+,|C0|1.70205*.06706974 25.377 .0000|,|C1|.31261*.02228784 14.026 .0000|,|C2|-.57513*.07336253 -7.840 .0000|,|C3|-.04586*.00588216 -7.797 .0000|,+-+-+,MAXIMUM LIKELIHOOD,+-+-+-+-+-+-+,|Variable|Coefficient|Standard Error|b/St.Er.|P|Z|z|Mean of X|,+-+-+-+-+-+-+,Constant|1.72492985 .02000568 86.222 .0000,FEMALE|.31954440 .00696870 45.854 .0000 .47877479,HHNINC|-.52475878 .02197021 -23.885 .0000 .35208362,EDUC|-.04986696 .00172872 -28.846 .0000 11.3206310,Testing Hypotheses,Wald tests,using the familiar distance measure,Likelihood ratio tests:,LogL,U,=log likelihood without restrictions,LogL,R,=log likelihood with restrictions,LogL,U,logL,R,for any nested restrictions,2(LogL,U,logL,R,),chi-squared J,The Lagrange multiplier test.Wald test of the hypothesis that the score of the,unrestricted,log likelihood,is zero when evaluated at the,restricted estimator,.,Testing the Model,+-+,|Poisson Regression|,|Maximum Likelihood Estimates|,|Dependent variable DOCVIS|,|Number of observations 27326|,|Iterations completed 7|,|Log likelihood function -106215.1|Log likelihood,|Number of parameters 4|,|Restricted log likelihood -108662.1|Log Likelihood with only a,|McFadden Pseudo R-squared .0225193|constant term.,|,Chi squared 4893.983,|2*logL logL(0),|Degrees of freedom 3|,|ProbChiSqd value=.0000000|,+-+,Likelihood ratio test that all three slopes are zero.,Wald Test,-MATRIX;List;b1=b(2:4);v11=varb(2:4,2:4);B1B1$,Matrix B1 Matrix V11,has 3 rows and 1 columns.has 3 rows and 3 columns,1 1 2 3,+-+-,1|.31954 1|.4856275D-04-.4556076D-06 .2169925D-05,2|-.52476 2|-.4556076D-06 .00048 -.9160558D-05,3|-.04987 3|.2169925D-05-.9160558D-05 .2988465D-05,Matrix Result has 1 rows and 1 columns.,1,+-,1|4682.38779 LR statistic was 4893.983,Likelihood Ratio Test,poisson;lhs=docvis,;rhs=one,female,hhninc,educ$,calc ;logL1=logL$,poisson;lhs=docvis,;rhs=one,hhninc,educ$,calc ;logL0=logL$,calc ;logLpool=logL$,poisson;forfemale=0;lhs=docvis,;rhs=one,hhninc,educ$,calc ;logLM=logL$,poisson;forfemale=1;lhs=docvis,;rhs=one,hhninc,educ$,calc ;logLF=logL$,?Chi squared test coefficient on FEMALE.1 Deg.Fr.,calc;list;logL1;logL0;LRM_F=2*(logL1-logL0)$,?Chi squared test for pooling.3 Deg.Fr.,calc ;list;logLM;loglF;logLpool,;LRGender=2*(logLM+logLF-logLpool)$,LR Test Results,-calc;list;logL1;logL0;LRM_F=2*(logL1-logL0)$,+-+,|Listed Calculator Results|,+-+,LOGL1 =-106215.144165,LOGL0 =-107277.287979,LRM_F =2124.287628,Calculator:Computed 3 scalar results,calc;list;loglM;loglF;logLpool,;LRGender=2*(logLM+logLF-logLpool)$,+-+,|Listed Calculator Results|,+-+,LOGLM =-51501.135803,LOGLF =-54656.153984,LOGLPOOL=-107277.287979,LRGENDER=2239.996383,LM Test,Hypothesis:3 slopes=0.MLE with all 3 slopes=0,=y-bar=exp(1),so MLE of 1 is log(y-bar).Constrained MLEs of other 3 slopes are zero.,LM Statistic,-calc ;beta1=log(xbr(docvis)$,-matrix;bmle0=beta1/0/0/0$,-create;lambda0=exp(xbmle0);res0=docvis-lambda0$,-matrix;list,;g0=xres0,;h0=xlambda0 x,;lm=g0*g0$,Matrix G0 has 4 rows and 1 columns.,+-,1|.2664385D-08,2|7944.94441,3|-1781.12219,4|-.3062440D+05,Matrix H0 has 4 rows and 4 columns.,+-,1|.8699300D+05 .4165006D+05 .3062881D+05 .9848157D+06,2|.4165006D+05 .4165006D+05 .1434824D+05 .4530019D+06,3|.3062881D+05 .1434824D+05 .1350638D+05 .3561238D+06,4|.9848157D+06 .4530019D+06 .3561238D+06 .1161892D+08,Matrix LM has 1 rows and 1 columns.,+-,1|4715.41008 Wald was 4682.38779 LR statistic was 4893.983,Applied Econometrics,William Greene,Department of Economics,Stern School of Business,Applied Econometrics,20.Aspects of Maximum,Likelihood Estimation,Invariance,Reparameterizing the Log Likelihood,Estimating the Tobit Model,
展开阅读全文